Debanhi Escobar: a 12 months of impunity within the case that grew to become a rallying cry over femicides in Mexico | Worldwide

A woman attaches a purple ribbon on a wall with images of Debanhi Escobar, in San Nicolás de los Garza, Mexico.
A girl attaches a purple ribbon on a wall with pictures of Debanhi Escobar, in San Nicolás de los Garza, Mexico.DANIEL BECERRIL (REUTERS)

It has been a 12 months since Mario Escobar emerged from the Nueva Castilla motel, on the outskirts of Monterrey, within the early hours and approached the press, saying via tears: “My daughter is useless and I don’t know what to do.” With these phrases, Mario Escobar confirmed that the physique that had been found inside an deserted cistern was that of 18-year-old Debanhi Escobar, who had been the main target of a 13-day search involving her household, native residents and a whole bunch of cops. The disappearance of the younger girl sparked misery all through Mexico and turned her into the nation’s newest image within the battle in opposition to femicides. The Debanhi Escobar case, which has nonetheless produced no solutions and no arrests, illustrates Mexico’s failure to realize justice for murdered girls.

“It has been three hundred and sixty five days since Debanhi was dumped in that motel; one 12 months since that atrocity was dedicated in opposition to our daughter,” Mario Escobar informed El PAÍS. He and his spouse, Dolores Bazaldúa, have known as for an indication this Friday in Monterrey, which can depart from the primary sq. of the state capital and head to the Nuevo León Prosecutor’s Workplace. In the end, the march will arrive on the Nueva Castilla motel to watch a minute of silence. “There are nonetheless many unanswered questions; what we’re searching for is justice and fact,” says Escobar.

Debanhi Escobar, the daughter of two academics, was a legislation scholar legislation on the Autonomous College of Nuevo León and preferred to bounce. On April 8, she went to a celebration with a gaggle of pals. Safety cameras captured her getting into and leaving a property within the municipality of Escobedo. On the primary journey, she was accompanied by two pals and on the return journey, she was alone. The identical driver took her each methods. She caught the cab to go residence at 4:17 a.m. however after touring just a few meters, she obtained out of the automotive on the freeway from Monterrey to Nuevo Laredo, in Tamaulipas — a notoriously harmful stretch of street the place a whole bunch of individuals disappeared throughout 2021. At that time, alone and together with her arms crossed, the driving force took {a photograph} of her.

What’s now recognized about that night time from safety digital camera footage is that Debanhi went to a transport firm positioned on the street to ask for assist. When she discovered it empty, she went to the Nueva Castilla motel. At 4:35 a.m., she is seen operating into the premises however, as pictures from the motel’s cameras present, as a substitute of going to reception she walked via the constructing and hid within the nook of a disused backyard. Round 20 minutes later, Debanhi is seen strolling by an empty pool and approaching the cistern. And that’s the final footage of her. “Within the final picture we have now, she is seen strolling alongside the facet of the fence subsequent to the place her stays had been discovered,” deputy prosecutor Luis Enrique Orozco stated after the safety digital camera footage got here to mild. After 13 days, motel workers discovered the younger girl’s physique contained in the cistern. A 12 months later, the query stays unanswered: how did she get there?

Mario Escobar and Dolores Bazaldúa, Debanhi Escobar's parents, in front of a mural in her memory in Monterrey last November.
Mario Escobar and Dolores Bazaldúa, Debanhi Escobar’s mother and father, in entrance of a mural in her reminiscence in Monterrey final November. Julio Cesar Aguilar

The Nuevo León Prosecutor’s Workplace initially put ahead the idea that Debanhi had fallen into the cistern by chance had died of a cranial contusion. This speculation was refuted by the outcomes of an extra post-mortem, the one which the household acknowledges as official and which required the exhumation of her physique. That post-mortem identifies the reason for loss of life as “asphyxia by suffocation as a consequence of obstruction of the respiratory orifices.” As well as, it establishes that the younger girl died between three and 5 days earlier than she was discovered. Which means Debanhi was alive for between eight and 10 days whereas lacking posters together with her {photograph} had been in every single place in Monterrey, her picture had gone viral all through Mexico and her disappearance had even reached the workplace of the president. The place was Debanhi throughout that point? And with whom? A 12 months later, there are nonetheless no solutions.

Irregularities within the case led to the dismissal of two prosecutors and, lastly, that of the state prosecutor, Gustavo Adolfo Guerrero. The authorities had been accused of negligence at each flip: the motel was supposedly searched on a number of events earlier than the physique was discovered and for 2 weeks it was claimed that there was no safety digital camera footage to assist find Debanhi — ultimately hours of video emerged from each from the transport firm and the motel itself. The investigation was taken over by the Legal professional Basic’s Workplace however there have been scarcely any particulars of its progress over the previous few months. Two workers of the motel have been linked to a judicial course of, accused of creating false declarations and concealment of data. So far, they’re the one two individuals who have been charged with something in relation to the case.

“There are zero detainees and the case remains to be open; we’re ready on the Legal professional Basic’s Workplace. There was some progress however little or no, not sufficient to result in the arrest of somebody,” says Mario Escobar, who regardless of the whole lot provides that the household preserve their confidence within the authorities: “We now have to hold on with a number of energy and preserve religion that the authorities will do the precise factor.”

The Debanhi Escobar case left a deep mark on younger girls in Mexico: the desperation of her mother and father in the course of the search, the delay to find her physique and the dearth of solutions as to who killed her, or why. In November, Lidia Gabriela Gómez, 23, leapt out of a transferring cab in Mexico Metropolis, believing she was being kidnapped. Her brother, Diego Maldonado, informed EL PAÍS that she was very distraught by what had occurred to Debanhi a number of months earlier: “She was very concerned within the feminist motion, and when Debanhi occurred, she stated: ‘If one thing like this occurs to me, if in the future they take me away in a automotive, I’d be higher off throwing myself out than being present in a vacant lot.’”

Join our weekly e-newsletter to get extra English-language information protection from EL PAÍS USA Version

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles